What Are the Requirements for Extrajudicial Settlement with Sale?

Introduction

An extrajudicial settlement with sale allows the heirs of a deceased person to divide the estate and transfer estate property to a third-party buyer without first securing a court order for settlement. It combines two transactions: the settlement or adjudication of the estate and the subsequent sale of the property.

This arrangement is permitted only when the legal requirements for extrajudicial settlement are satisfied. The heirs must also comply with registration, publication, tax, and documentary requirements before the buyer can obtain a new certificate of title.

What Is an Extrajudicial Settlement with Sale?

An extrajudicial settlement with sale is a public instrument in which the heirs identify and settle the estate of the deceased and, in the same instrument or in a related deed, sell the inherited property to a buyer.

The instrument may be structured as an extrajudicial settlement with sale, or the heirs may execute two separate documents: an extrajudicial settlement followed by a deed of absolute sale. In either case, the estate settlement must be valid before the heirs can transfer ownership to the buyer.

What Law Governs the Transaction?

The principal rule is Section 1, Rule 74 of the Rules of Court. It permits heirs to divide the estate without securing letters of administration when the decedent left no will and no debts, and when all heirs are of age or the minors are represented by duly authorized judicial or legal representatives.

The rule allows the heirs to divide the estate by means of a public instrument filed with the Register of Deeds. If there is only one heir, that heir may adjudicate the entire estate through an affidavit filed with the Register of Deeds. If the heirs disagree, they may pursue an ordinary action for partition instead of judicial administration.

The same requirements are reflected in Heirs of Arturo E. Bandoy, et al. v. Bandoy, General Register No. 255258, 2022, and in Buot v. Dujali, General Register No. 199885, 2017. These decisions explain that judicial administration is not ordinarily required when the estate has no debts and the heirs can settle or partition the property among themselves.

Who May Execute the Settlement?

The deed must generally be executed by all heirs concerned. A deed signed by only some heirs cannot bind heirs who did not participate and had no notice of the transaction.

Minors may be included only if they are represented by their judicial or legal representatives duly authorized for that purpose. The authority must be sufficient to permit the representative to participate in the settlement and, where applicable, authorize the sale of the minor’s inherited interest.

In The Roman Catholic Bishop of Tuguegarao v. Prudencio, et al., General Register No. 187942, 2016, the Court held that an extrajudicial partition excluding heirs without their knowledge or participation is void as to the excluded heirs. A buyer from an heir who obtained title through such a defective partition acquires no better right than the seller had.

What Are the Basic Requirements?

The following conditions must generally be present before an extrajudicial settlement with sale may be used:

• The decedent left no will, or the transaction is otherwise legally authorized despite the existence of testamentary dispositions.
• The estate has no outstanding debts, or the debts have already been paid.
• All heirs are of age, or minors are properly represented and authorized.
• All heirs concerned participate in and sign the settlement.
• The settlement is executed in a public instrument.
• The settlement is published in a newspaper of general circulation once a week for three consecutive weeks.
• The deed is registered with the proper Register of Deeds.
• The required bond is filed when required under Rule 74.
• The estate and sale taxes are paid and the required certificates authorizing registration are obtained.

What Must the Deed Contain?

The deed should accurately identify the deceased, the heirs, the estate property, the buyer, and the consideration for the sale. It should also state the circumstances supporting extrajudicial settlement, including the absence of a will and debts, when applicable.

For titled real property, the deed should include the complete technical description appearing on the certificate of title. It should also state the title number, tax declaration details when relevant, the parties’ civil status, and the extent of the interest being transferred.

The document should clearly distinguish between the settlement or adjudication of the estate and the sale to the third-party buyer. Ambiguous wording may create problems in assessing taxes, issuing electronic certificates authorizing registration, and registering the transfer.

Is Publication Required?

Yes. Under Section 86 of the Property Registration Decree, P.D. No. 1529, no deed of extrajudicial settlement or affidavit of adjudication may be registered unless the fact of the settlement or adjudication is published once a week for three consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the province.

Proof of publication must be filed with the Register of Deeds. This may consist of a certification from the publisher, printer, foreman, principal clerk, editor, business manager, or advertising manager of the newspaper, or copies of the newspaper issues in which the publication appeared.

Publication does not replace the requirement that all heirs participate or receive notice. Under Rule 74, an extrajudicial settlement does not bind a person who did not participate in it and had no notice of it.

What Is the Rule 74 Bond?

The parties to an extrajudicial settlement must file a bond with the Register of Deeds simultaneously with, and as a condition precedent to, the filing of the public instrument. The bond is generally equivalent to the value of the personal property involved, as certified under oath by the parties, and is intended to answer for just claims that may later be filed under Section 4 of Rule 74.

The bond and the settlement do not extinguish legitimate claims of creditors or persons who were improperly excluded. Rule 74 protects creditors and omitted heirs by allowing appropriate claims within the period provided by law.

What Is the Two-Year Lien?

When the deed is registered, the Register of Deeds annotates on the title the two-year lien mentioned in Section 4 of Rule 74. Section 86 of P.D. No. 1529 recognizes this annotation and provides a procedure for its cancellation after the two-year period.

After two years, the registered heirs, devisees, legatees, or another interested party may file a verified petition stating that no claim of a creditor, heir, or other person exists. Upon presentation of the petition, the Register of Deeds may cancel the lien without a court order, subject to the statutory requirements.

The lien is not a guarantee that the settlement can never be challenged. An omitted heir or creditor may still pursue the remedy allowed by Rule 74 when the facts support it.

How Does the Sale Affect the Transaction?

The sale to the buyer is a separate transfer of ownership from the estate or heirs to the purchaser. The heirs must have authority to sell the property, and the settlement must validly establish their ownership or transferable interests.

If one heir sells the entire property without the participation of the other heirs, that heir generally cannot transfer more than the interest legally belonging to that heir. The buyer may acquire only the seller’s actual share and may not defeat the rights of the other heirs.

In The Roman Catholic Bishop of Tuguegarao v. Prudencio, et al., General Register No. 187942, 2016, the Court applied this principle where an excluded heir was not bound by the defective partition. The buyer’s good faith did not enlarge the rights acquired from the seller.

What Tax and Registration Documents Are Usually Needed?

The parties should coordinate with the Bureau of Internal Revenue and the Register of Deeds before signing or submitting the documents. The usual requirements include proof of payment or clearance of applicable estate and transfer taxes, the death certificate, the original certificate of title or owner’s duplicate when required, tax declarations, valid identification documents, and proof of publication.

Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 85-2018 treats the estate settlement and the subsequent sale or donation as two transactions. When an extrajudicial settlement with sale or an extrajudicial settlement followed by a separate deed of sale is submitted, two electronic Certificates Authorizing Registration are generally issued—one for the estate settlement and another for the sale or donation.

The two electronic certificates must be presented simultaneously to the Registry of Deeds when required by the Bureau of Internal Revenue process. Presenting only one may result in the invalidation of the other transaction in the system.

What Documents Should the Heirs Prepare?

A typical transaction file should include the following:

• Death certificate of the decedent.
• Extrajudicial settlement with sale, or separate extrajudicial settlement and deed of absolute sale.
• Birth certificates, marriage certificates, or other civil registry records proving heirship.
• Original or certified true copy of the certificate of title.
• Current tax declaration and property tax clearance, when required.
• Proof of publication for three consecutive weeks.
• Rule 74 bond, when required.
• Bureau of Internal Revenue clearance and electronic certificates authorizing registration.
• Valid identification documents and tax identification numbers of the heirs and buyer.
• Corporate authorization documents if the buyer is a corporation or other juridical entity.

The exact checklist may vary depending on the Register of Deeds, the revenue district office, the property’s location, the parties’ civil status, and whether the property is subject to agrarian reform, a mortgage, annotation, adverse claim, or pending litigation.

What If the Estate Has Debts?

Extrajudicial settlement under Rule 74 is generally unavailable when the estate has unpaid debts. The heirs should first determine whether creditors exist and whether the estate can lawfully be settled without prejudicing them.

If the heirs disagree, or if the estate requires court-supervised administration, an ordinary partition action or a proper special proceeding may be necessary. In Buot v. Dujali, General Register No. 199885, 2017, the Court explained that disputes among heirs do not automatically require administration when partition can adequately resolve the controversy.

Can an Excluded Heir Challenge the Sale?

Yes. An heir who did not participate in the settlement and had no notice may challenge the settlement and the resulting transfer to the extent that the transaction affects that heir’s share.

In The Roman Catholic Bishop of Tuguegarao v. Prudencio, et al., General Register No. 187942, 2016, the Court held that an extrajudicial partition excluding heirs without their knowledge or participation is void and inexistent as against them. The buyer may therefore be unable to acquire the excluded heir’s interest.

Heirs should therefore establish the complete family tree and obtain civil registry documents before preparing the deed. The omission of even one compulsory or intestate heir may result in litigation and prevent clean registration.

Can Heirs File Partition Instead of Administration?

Yes. When the heirs cannot agree on the division or sale, they may file an ordinary action for partition. The action may also include related claims involving ownership, possession, annulment of documents, or cancellation of title when the allegations and evidence support those remedies.

In Villafria, et al. v. Riñoza Plazo, et al., General Register No. 187524, 2015, the Court recognized that a partition action does not automatically become a special proceeding merely because it involves determining heirs, ownership, or the validity of documents.

Typical Example

A parent dies intestate, leaving a titled residential lot to three adult children. The estate has no unpaid debts, and all three children agree to transfer the lot to a buyer.

The children may execute a public instrument identifying themselves as heirs, settling and adjudicating the property, and selling it to the buyer. They must comply with publication, the Rule 74 bond requirement, tax requirements, and registration procedures. The buyer should verify that all heirs signed and that the required certificates authorizing registration are available.

If a fourth child later proves that the child was an heir and did not participate or receive notice, the fourth child may challenge the settlement and assert the corresponding share against the transaction.

Recommended Procedure

1. Confirm the date and fact of death and obtain the death certificate.
2. Determine whether the decedent left a will, debts, surviving spouse, compulsory heirs, or other persons with possible claims.
3. Establish the complete list of heirs through civil registry records and other competent documents.
4. Verify the title, tax declaration, liens, encumbrances, annotations, and property classification.
5. Prepare the extrajudicial settlement with sale or separate settlement and sale documents.
6. Execute the documents before the proper notary public.
7. Complete publication for three consecutive weeks and obtain proof of publication.
8. Process the estate and sale taxes and secure the required electronic certificates authorizing registration.
9. File the bond and submit the complete documents to the Register of Deeds.
10. Confirm that the new title, tax declaration, and annotations correctly reflect the buyer’s ownership and any remaining liens.

Final Observations

An extrajudicial settlement with sale is available when the estate can be settled without court administration and all affected heirs properly participate. The transaction is not merely a private sale: it requires a valid estate settlement, publication, protection for creditors and omitted heirs, tax compliance, and registration.

Before signing, the heirs and buyer should verify the complete heirship records, title history, unpaid obligations, and registration requirements. If there is an omitted heir, unresolved debt, conflicting claim, minor heir, or disputed property interest, court proceedings or a judicial partition may be safer than relying on a defective extrajudicial settlement.

About Nicolas and De Vega Law Offices

 Nicolas and de Vega Law Offices is a full-service law firm in the Philippines.  You may visit us at the 16th Flr., Suite 1607 AIC Burgundy Empire Tower, ADB Ave., Ortigas Center, 1605 Pasig City, Metro Manila, Philippines.  You may also call us at +632 84706126, +632 84706130, +632 84016392 or e-mail us at [email protected].