How Can Shares of a Delinquent Stockholder Be Confiscated?
Introduction
A stockholder who fails to pay an unpaid capital subscription does not automatically lose the subscribed shares. Under Philippine corporate law, the corporation must first comply with the statutory requirements for declaring the subscription due, classifying the shares as delinquent, giving notice, and conducting a delinquency sale.
The term “confiscation” is commonly used to describe the corporation’s recovery of unpaid shares. Legally, however, the process is a delinquency sale. The corporation may acquire the shares as treasury shares only when the statutory procedure produces no qualified bidder and the corporation properly bids for the shares.
Governing Law
The principal rules appear in Sections 66 to 70 of the Revised Corporation Code of the Philippines, or R.A. No. 11232. These provisions govern the collection of unpaid subscriptions, delinquency sales, court actions, and the voting consequences of delinquent shares.
Section 66 allows the board of directors to declare unpaid subscriptions due and payable, subject to the subscription contract. The stockholder must pay on the date stated in the subscription contract or in the board’s call. If payment is not made, the entire unpaid balance becomes due, unless the applicable contract provides otherwise.
If no payment is made within thirty days from the due date, the shares covered by the subscription become delinquent and may be sold under the procedure prescribed by the Revised Corporation Code. The rule is stated in [Revised Corporation Code, Sec. 66](#L1.80).
When Does a Subscription Become Delinquent?
A subscription becomes delinquent only after the following events occur:
- The subscription contract or board call specifies the payment date;
- The stockholder fails to pay the amount due on that date;
- The unpaid balance becomes due and payable, with applicable interest; and
- No payment is made within thirty days from the due date.
The board should maintain complete records of the subscription, the amount paid, the unpaid balance, the payment date, the board call, and all communications with the stockholder. A delinquency resolution based on incomplete or inaccurate records may be challenged.
Timeline for a Delinquency Sale
1. The Board Declares the Subscription Due
The board of directors must first act pursuant to the subscription contract. It may declare the unpaid subscription, or a specified percentage of it, due and payable. The resolution should identify the stockholder, the subscription, the amount due, the applicable interest, and the payment deadline.
The board cannot disregard a payment schedule expressly stated in the subscription contract. Its authority must be exercised consistently with the contract and the Revised Corporation Code.
2. The Stockholder Receives the Payment Deadline
Payment must be made on the date stated in the subscription contract or on the date specified in the board’s call. Failure to pay makes the unpaid balance due and may result in interest at the legal rate, unless a different rate is validly provided in the subscription contract.
The corporation should preserve proof that the call and payment demand were properly issued and transmitted. The date of actual notice may become important if the stockholder disputes the delinquency or the subsequent sale.
3. The Shares Become Delinquent After Thirty Days
If the stockholder does not pay within thirty days from the specified due date, all shares covered by the unpaid subscription become delinquent, unless the board orders otherwise.
The delinquency generally affects the entire subscription covered by the unpaid obligation. SEC-OGC Opinion No. 10-15 and SEC-OGC Opinion No. 16-05 recognize the indivisibility of a stock subscription and reject the practice of treating only the paid portion as independently transferable while the subscription remains unpaid.
4. The Board Orders the Delinquency Sale
After the shares become delinquent, the board may adopt a resolution ordering their sale. The resolution must specifically state:
- The amount due on each subscription;
- Accrued interest;
- The date, time, and place of the public auction; and
- The basis for the sale under the subscription records and the Revised Corporation Code.
The auction date must be not earlier than thirty days and not later than sixty days from the date the shares become delinquent. This period is mandatory. The corporation should calculate the deadline carefully and record the calculation in the board and corporate secretary’s files.
5. The Corporation Gives Notice and Publishes the Sale
Notice of the sale, together with a copy of the board resolution, must be sent to every delinquent stockholder. The statute permits personal delivery, registered mail, or another method provided in the corporation’s bylaws.
The sale must also be published once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the province or city where the corporation’s principal office is located.
Notice is not a mere formality. A stockholder facing the loss of property must receive a meaningful opportunity to pay the balance and prevent the sale. In Calatagan Golf Club, Inc. v. Clemente, Jr., G.R. No. 165443, 19 February 2009, the Supreme Court emphasized that a corporation must comply with its bylaws and act in good faith when enforcing remedies that may deprive a member of property or membership rights.
If mailed notices are repeatedly returned because the corporation knows that the address is closed or ineffective, sending another notice to the same address may not satisfy the corporation’s duty of good faith. The corporation should use the stockholder’s latest recorded address and comply with any additional notice requirements in its bylaws.
6. The Stockholder May Prevent the Sale
Before the auction date, the delinquent stockholder may prevent the sale by paying:
- The unpaid balance of the subscription;
- Accrued interest;
- Publication and advertising costs; and
- Expenses of the sale.
The corporation should issue a written computation of the amount required for redemption before the auction. It should also document the date and manner of payment and issue the corresponding corporate receipt.
7. The Public Auction Is Conducted
If the stockholder does not pay and the board does not cancel or postpone the sale, the shares must be sold at public auction. The successful bidder must offer to pay the full amount due, including interest, publication costs, and sale expenses, in exchange for the smallest number of shares or fraction of a share.
This bidding formula is significant. The purpose is to satisfy the subscription debt while exposing the smallest possible portion of the delinquent stock to sale. The bidder does not simply acquire all shares automatically.
What Happens After the Auction?
The shares purchased at the auction must be transferred to the purchaser in the corporation’s books, and a certificate of stock must be issued in the purchaser’s name. Any remaining shares must be credited to the delinquent stockholder, who is entitled to a certificate covering those remaining shares.
The corporate secretary should prepare an auction report identifying the bidders, the winning bid, the amount paid, the number of shares sold, and the shares remaining for the delinquent stockholder.
What If There Is No Qualified Bidder?
If no bidder offers to pay the full amount due for the smallest number of shares or fraction of a share, the corporation may bid for the shares, subject to the Revised Corporation Code.
When the corporation is the successful bidder, the total amount due is credited as fully paid in the corporate books. Title to all shares covered by the subscription becomes vested in the corporation as treasury shares. The corporation may later dispose of those treasury shares in accordance with the Revised Corporation Code.
This is the circumstance most closely resembling “confiscation.” It is not an informal cancellation of the stockholder’s shares. It is an acquisition by the corporation through the statutory delinquency-sale process.
The rule on the corporation’s bid and treasury shares appears in [Revised Corporation Code, Sec. 67](#L1.82).
Can the Corporation Simply Cancel the Shares?
No. The corporation cannot simply cancel the shares, erase the stockholder’s name, or transfer the subscription to itself without following the statutory process.
The proper remedies are a delinquency sale under Section 67 of the Revised Corporation Code or a court action to recover the unpaid subscription under Section 69. The corporation may also consider a negotiated settlement if authorized by the board and consistent with the subscription contract and applicable corporate rules.
Section 69 expressly provides that the corporation may recover the amount due on an unpaid subscription through court action, including accrued interest, costs, and expenses. This remedy is separate from, and does not eliminate, the delinquency-sale procedure. See [Revised Corporation Code, Sec. 69](#L1.84).
Voting and Other Rights of a Delinquent Stockholder
A delinquent stockholder cannot vote the delinquent shares, cannot be represented by those shares at a stockholders’ meeting, and cannot exercise the other rights of a stockholder until the subscription obligation is paid in accordance with law.
The statutory exception is the right to receive dividends under the conditions stated in the Revised Corporation Code. Section 70 provides the principal rule on the effects of delinquency. See [Revised Corporation Code, Sec. 70](#L1.85).
SEC-OGC Opinion No. 10-27 likewise recognizes that delinquent shares are excluded from voting and representation at stockholders’ meetings. The corporation should therefore review the status of shares when determining voting strength and meeting participation.
Are Partial Transfers of Unpaid Subscriptions Allowed?
Generally, no. A subscription contract is treated as indivisible while the subscription remains unpaid. A stockholder should not be issued a separate certificate for the paid portion while the remaining portion of the same subscription is delinquent.
SEC-OGC Opinion No. 10-15 states that a delinquent subscription cannot be divided into a paid portion that remains fully recognized and an unpaid portion that alone is subjected to sale. SEC-OGC Opinion No. 16-05 similarly affirms that no stock certificate may be issued until the subscription is fully paid, subject to the governing corporate law and valid corporate records.
Common Errors That May Invalidate the Process
- Declaring delinquency without a valid payment call or without checking the subscription contract;
- Using an auction date outside the thirty-to-sixty-day statutory period;
- Failing to state the amount due, interest, and auction details in the board resolution;
- Sending notice to an outdated address despite knowledge that it will not reach the stockholder;
- Failing to publish the notice for two consecutive weeks; and
- Transferring all shares to the corporation without a public auction or a proper corporate bid.
Corporations should also verify their bylaws. The bylaws may prescribe additional notice, recordkeeping, or approval requirements. Compliance with the minimum statutory procedure does not excuse a corporation from complying with its own bylaws.
Illustrative Example
Assume that a stockholder subscribed to 10,000 shares and paid only the required initial amount. The board validly calls the unpaid balance due on 1 March. If the stockholder does not pay within thirty days, the subscription becomes delinquent on 31 March, subject to the precise computation of the applicable period.
The board may order a sale scheduled between thirty and sixty days from the date the shares became delinquent. It must send the notice and board resolution to the stockholder and publish the notice once a week for two consecutive weeks.
If a bidder pays the entire amount due for 4,000 shares, those shares are transferred to the bidder. The remaining 6,000 shares are credited to the delinquent stockholder. If no bidder submits the required offer, the corporation may bid, credit the amount due as fully paid, and hold all 10,000 shares as treasury shares.
Recommended Corporate Checklist
- Review the subscription contract, bylaws, stock and transfer book, and payment records.
- Compute the unpaid balance, interest, publication costs, and sale expenses accurately.
- Adopt a board resolution declaring the subscription due, when appropriate.
- Record the due date and determine when the thirty-day delinquency period ends.
- Adopt a separate resolution ordering the sale and specify all required auction details.
- Serve notice using a legally permitted method and the stockholder’s latest recorded address.
- Publish the notice once a week for two consecutive weeks.
- Allow payment before the auction, including lawful costs and interest.
- Conduct the auction according to the smallest-number-of-shares bidding rule.
- Record the result in the corporate books and issue certificates only in accordance with law.
Conclusion
A delinquent stockholder’s shares cannot be informally confiscated. The corporation must follow the statutory timeline for payment, delinquency, notice, publication, and public auction under the Revised Corporation Code.
The corporation may acquire the shares as treasury shares only when no qualified bidder appears and the corporation properly bids for the shares. Before proceeding, the board and corporate secretary should verify the subscription contract, bylaws, notices, publication records, computations, and auction documents. If procedural defects or disputed facts exist, a court action to recover the unpaid subscription may be safer than an improperly conducted sale.
About Nicolas and De Vega Law Offices
Nicolas and de Vega Law Offices is a full-service law firm in the Philippines. You may visit us at the 16th Flr., Suite 1607 AIC Burgundy Empire Tower, ADB Ave., Ortigas Center, 1605 Pasig City, Metro Manila, Philippines. You may also call us at +632 84706126, +632 84706130, +632 84016392 or e-mail us at [email protected]. Visit our website https://ndvlaw.com.
